Olivier Blanchard, former director of the IMF’s research
department, has written a short critical piece
about DSGE models. Forget all the econblog reaction that essentially
says he has been too kind: DSGE completely dominates academic
macroeconomics, and there is no way that all these academics are
going to suddenly decide this research programme is a waste of time.
(I happen to think Blanchard is right that it isn’t a waste of
time.) What is at issue is not the existence of DSGE models, but
their hegemony.
One of Blanchard’s recommendations is that DSGE “has to become
less imperialistic. Or, perhaps more fairly, the profession (and
again, this is a note to the editors of the major journals) must
realize that different model types are needed for different tasks.”
The most important part of that sentence is the bit in brackets. He
talks about a distinction between fully microfounded models and
‘policy models’. The latter used to be called
Structural Econometric Models (SEMs), and they are the type of model
that Lucas and Sargent famously attacked.
These SEMs have survived
as the core model used in many important policy institutions (except
for the Bank of England) for good reason, but DSGE trained academics
have followed Lucas and Sargent as viewing these as not ‘proper
macroeconomics’. Their reasoning is simply wrong, as I discuss
here.
As Blanchard notes, it is the editors of top journals that need to
realise this, and stop insisting that all aggregate models have to be
microfounded. The moment they allow space for eclecticism, then
academics will be able to choose which methods they use.
Blanchard has one other ‘note for editors’ remark, and it also
gets to the heart of the problem with today’s macroeconomics. He
writes “Not every discussion of a new mechanism should be required
to come with a complete general equilibrium closure.” The example
he discusses, and which I have also used in this context, is
consumption. DSGE modellers have of course often departed from the
simple Euler equation, but I suspect the ways they have done this
(rule of thumb consumers, habits) reflect analytical convenience
rather than realism.
What sometimes seems to be missing in macro nowadays is a connection
between people working on partial equilibrium analysis (like
consumption) and general equilibrium modellers. Top journal editors’
preference for the latter means that the former is less highly
valued. In my view this has already had important costs. I argue that
the failure to take seriously the strong evidence about the
importance of changes in credit availability for consumption played
an important part in the inability of macroeconomics to adequately
model the response to the financial crisis (for more discussion see
here
and here).
Even if you do not accept that, the failure of most DSGE models to
include any kind of precautionary saving behaviour does not seem
right when DSGE has a monopoly in ‘proper modelling’. [1]
Criticism of the DSGE hegemony from those outside economics, from
macroeconomists who are not part of it, or even from economic
policymakers has had little impact on those all important journal
editors up until now. Perhaps similar comments from one of the best
macroeconomists in the world might.
[1] I discuss the reasons why this may have occurred in relation to
Chris Carroll’s work here.