Suppose a scientist finds that a product being used by some industry
to help enhance their products is in fact dangerous. Their research
is peer reviewed by other scientists, who find no fault. Imagine
there are no regulatory bodies that the scientist can pass this
information to. She contacts politicians and civil servants, but the
government is too close to the industry and the opposition are too
busy on other things.
She contacts the media. Most journalists do not have time to
understand what she has done, check that other scientists agree with
the results and write it up, while others know that because the
industry advertises with their paper any story will be spiked. She
gets invited on to one TV programme, where she finds herself pitted
against an industry representative practiced at PR who dismisses what
she has done. Nothing happens as a result.
How do we stop this kind of thing happening? Do we suggest that the
scientist gets some media training so she can debate better on TV, or
hires a PR company so that more journalists take notice of what she
has done? Or do we lambaste journalists for not doing their job
properly, imagining we are still in a bygone era where journalists
had time to investigate?
In this particular example most countries have chosen a better model,
where they set up regulatory bodies staffed with other scientists
that have the job of assessing research of this kind, bodies which
governments find it difficult to ignore. But what happens if, for
whatever reason, these institutions do not exist?
In the space of two years the UK has had three referendums/elections
in which economic issues have been key. In the Scottish independence
referendum and Brexit the view of the overwhelming majority of
economists have been clear [1], but in the media this view was/is
typically ‘balanced’ by an opposing view. In the UK election the
views of macroeconomists on austerity were more diffuse, but a clear
majority
did not think austerity had a positive effect on the economy. The
media largely ignored this view.
I naturally think there is something wrong here, and I also doubt
that the answer is to give macroeconomists more media training. We
need a debate about what the right answer is. [2]
[1] In the Scottish referendum the clear view
was that there would be large short term fiscal costs arising from
independence.
[2] My thanks to the
organisers of this event
for starting this debate, and in particular to members of the
audience whose questions this post is a better answer to!